saqua608 (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

If you are talking about vocals only then, yes, I one hundred percent agree with your top 3 but on the flip side I think that the American Idol needed to be someone who was personable too. People always blast this competition because people vote on popularity but SOME of it has to be a popularity thing, who would vote for some they didn't like. That said I think the top 5 should have been David C, David A, Jason, Brooke and Carly, (with DC winnning) cuz they were likeable and talented.

curlingiron7658 (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

This was hands down one of the best perofrmances of the season....

jairussr124ever (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

carly is greatfact,she is the winner for meher voice rocks very wellshe's my idolshe just forgive other contestantsbutshe is the true winner

kmmangel444 (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

Why do all these contestants sound alike?

sanjayalover95 (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

she desserved to go so much farther than 6

hattiehedgehog (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

i don't agree with brooke i think the top 3 should have been michael, carly and david cook. i didn't think brooke was that good a singer

hearted4ever (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

something else: this song makes me happy, its wonderful

hearted4ever (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

Michael, Brooke and her are the best from that season

hattiehedgehog (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

i don't see how she could have got voted off after this performance! it was the second best performance of the night (after david cook) i mean jason was terrible that night (as always) he shoukd have got voted off instead

monkeybutt789 (December 31, 1969 at 6:59 pm)

this was her most amazing performance ever. so notttt fair she got voted off cuz of this.:/